Michigan Politics
Somewhere between spurring Michigan’s economic recovery and protecting its environment there is a better future for this very troubled state, leader in joblessness.
Ann Arbor businessman Rick Snyder, who has had leadership roles on both fronts, is ratcheting up the case that he knows the balanced path to that future and can get Michigan there as its next governor.
Snyder, who last week touted environmental protection in the sixth of his “Top 10 Guiding Principles to Reinventing Michigan,” has been campaigning in relative obscurity for the GOP nomination. His position papers, thoughtful as they are, have been getting limited media, and scant public, attention.
In all polls to date, the venture capitalist and former boss at Gateway computers far trails better known contenders: Attorney General Mike Cox, high-profile chaser of evil-doers; Congressman Pete Hoekstra of Holland, who as top Republican on the House Intelligence Committee is a regular on TV networks; and Oakland County Sheriff Mike Bouchard, a former state senator and 2006 challenger of Senator Debbie Stabenow.
But Snyder hopes to pull off a Scott Brown – come back from way down in polls in the primary as Republican Brown did last week in the Massachusetts special election to win the seat held for nearly a half-century by the late Democratic Senator Ted Kennedy. “The Fall of the House of Kennedy,” headlined the Wall Street Journal.
The dynamics are entirely different in Michigan. But Snyder is using some of the same strategists (most notably former John McCain adviser John Weaver) used by Brown, and, Snyder said Friday, “the same technology” that Brown used, including GPSenabled tracking of voter locations.
Snyder, who has raised $3.2 million for his campaign (including at least $340,000 of his own money as of what was revealed in October), plans early in February to launch a TV ad campaign that will give visibility to his plans.
Last week, Snyder, a former chairman of the Michigan Economic Development Corporation and until recently a member of the board of trustees of the Michigan Chapter of the Nature Conservancy, said in his latest position paper: “The state must become a conservation leader again because Michigan’s citizens value the natural environment
over Lansing’s worn-out political environment.”
Snyder said, “Politicians are jeopardizing our resources and compromising our reputation as a leader in environmental stewardship. ...Public and private partnerships provide a sustainable funding model to stem the tide.”
Snyder’s paper is sparse on specifics, but one proposal worthy of note is his call for a “Rapid Response Mechanism – the state needs to use resources and create partnerships that can serve as Michigan’s quick reaction force to inhibit and eventually eradicate environmental threats before they create irreversible damage.”
Too often, Michigan has lacked rapid response to environmental threats. An environmental Swat Team might have helped prevent the current mess at Bay Harbor near Petoskey, where acidic leachate from cement processing is migrating into Lake Michigan.
Traverse City environmental attorney Jim Olson, point man on many natural resource legal issues, correctly says: “Public and private partnerships are fine, but this should not be a substitute for a strong regulatory backdrop to encourage such partnerships; if he's talking about partnerships to protect and preserve areas like our state parks, rivers, lakes, natural areas under the new ‘Department of Natural Resources and Environment,’ then this is necessary in these economic times. But this should not be a substitute for broad oversight and enforcement.”
I also sought reaction to Snyder’s paper from Dave Dempsey, formerly with the Michigan Environment Council; environmental adviser to ex- Governor Jim Blanchard; transition adviser to Governor Jennifer Granholm, and author of “Great Lakes for Sale” from University of Michigan Press on commercialization of water of the lakes.
He notes Snyder’s “good values” in some areas but said he lacks specifics in many.
Dempsey said that considering how the two latest governors – Republican John Engler and Democrat Jennifer Granholm – “failed to follow their very lengthy conservation platforms, I don't give these things much weight anymore.”
Good point. But it’s still good to see at least one current candidate for governor issue a lengthy white paper on green issues. Those who care about such matters need to ask all candidates about specifics.
Among questions I had last week of Snyder:
• Does he agree with U.S. Rep Bart Stupak, D-Menominee, (as well as Olson and Dempsey) that the Great Lakes Compact needs to be to be revised, or that Congress should reject "commoditization" of water – not treating Great Lakes water as a product?
• What’s his view on slant, or directional, drilling into the Great Lakes?
Snyder spokesman Jake Suski responded: “Rick wants to evaluate the science behind both topics more closely to make sure that the relationship between the risk and the benefit are acceptable. He believes that there have been significant improvements in directional drilling in the last decade.”
Camp Combats Carp
Cheers to U.S. Representative Dave Camp (R-Midland) for his bill calling “for the immediate closure of all Asian Carp pathways into the Great Lakes.” Subsequently, Senator Debbie Stabenow introduced a similar bill in the Senate.
They acted after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected Cox’s request for the closing.
“It is clear that Asian carp pose an immediate threat to the Great Lakes, its ecosystem, and the 800,000 jobs it supports,” said Camp. “The failure of the Supreme Court to act…jeopardizes the future of the Lakes and it is clear we must take additional steps now.”
Camp’s CARP ACT stands for “Close All Routes and Prevent Asian Carp Today.”
Camp, ranking Republican on the House Ways and Means Committee, has been one of his party’s lead voices on the health care issue on Capitol Hill.
Last week, participating in the National Press Club speaker series on health care, Camp said this of impact of Scott Brown’s victory: “...after two decades in this business, and receiving close to 65 percent of the vote in a district President Obama carried, I am capable and even pretty good at taking a political pulse. So, I am confident in this diagnosis: on Tuesday, January 12, 2010, the people of Massachusetts – one of the bluest states in the nation – declared dead the Democrats’ misguided, $1 trillion, government-takeover of health care.”
Another Dem Dropout
It was a surprise when Lieutenant Governor John Cherry, frontrunner for the Democratic nomination, withdrew from the governor’s race, citing difficulty in raising money.
That prompted Senator Hansen Clarke of Detroit to enter the race, but he quit it a week later, contemplating a run for Congress. Ex-Representative John Freeman of Madison Heights also was a January dropout from the governor’s race, saying needed money “was out of reach.”
Last week, Senator Gretchen Whitmer of East Lansing, a potentially strong Democratic contender for attorney general, was a surprise dropout, citing concern that a statewide race would leave too little time to spend with her two young daughters.
My bet was on her for the party convention nomination. Still contending are Genesee County Prosecutor David Leyton and Farmington Hills attorney Richard Bernstein, member of the Wayne County University Board of Governors.
Another Duty for Schuette?
Meanwhile, multi-tasking Bill Schuette of Midland – former congressman, U.S. Senate nominee (1990), state senator, state agriculture director and, most recently and relevant, ex- Michigan Appeals Court Judge – is on a roll in lining up endorsements to be Republican nominee for attorney general.
Last week, he brought to 30 the number of endorsements from county prosecutors, adding to his list those from Alger, Antrim, Baraga, Benzie, Charlevoix, Leelanau, Manistee, and Tuscola counties.
Schuette also has an impressive number of endorsements from lawmakers and county and district party leaders. AG campaign trumpets have yet to blare for Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop of Rochester and Senator Bruce Patterson of Canton, currently focused on their current duties.
In any event, for both parties, much will depend on how the winners of the August 3 gubernatorial primaries want the state conventions to balance the party tickets. And, in the case of the Democratic ticket, the wishes of organized labor.
George Weeks retired in 2006 after 22 years as political columnist for The Detroit News. His weekly Michigan Politics column is syndicated by Superior Features.
- Login to post comments
-









